Author Archives: Thrasymachus

About Thrasymachus

Thrasymachus is a junior doctor and amateur philosopher in the UK.

How good were the old greats?

Summary: In many fields, the ‘greatest’ (be they philosophers, playwrights, composers, etc.) are selected disproportionately more from those who lived in the distant past. I speculate as to what might be driving this bias towards ‘ancient greatness’, but one important… continue reading »


I am now a doctor. The result that I passed my finals came on Friday, and the declaration happened Sunday afternoon. I start work as the most junior of junior doctors – a Foundation Year 1 – at the end… continue reading »

God, Evil, and Appearances: A Dialogue

[Published in THINK (2013; issue 12, pp 9-23)] ADAM: Consider this: Neil and Kazumi Puttick, and their son Sam were, by all accounts, an idyllic family. One friend said: ‘If you could bottle up a perfect marriage, theirs would be… continue reading »

Why you shouldn’t believe the Resurrection happened

The 12th (and final) part in “20 Atheist answers to questions they supposedly can’t.” What accounts for the empty tomb, resurrection appearances and growth of the church? Short answer: We shouldn’t be that confident of these facts, but in any… continue reading »

Unfriendly AI cannot be the Great Filter

[Slightly odd topic, originally posted on LessWrong.] Introduction The Great Filter is the idea that although there is lots of matter, we observe no “expanding, lasting life”, like space-faring intelligences. So there is some filter through which almost all matter… continue reading »

Atheist Prayer Experiment: Conclusion

Several weeks late, but never mind. I was another one of those who got no answer, despite my best efforts. If anything, my life was marginally less numinous than usual: nothing resembling spiritual longing, my life was slightly more fraught… continue reading »

In defence of the Genetic Fallacy

Many objections to religious belief take the form of ‘debunking arguments’. On these views, religious belief is a manifestation of class oppression, or psycho-sexual disfunction, of some evolution-inspired psychological glitch (agency detection) or similar. An objector might want to nail… continue reading »

Atheist Prayer Experiment, Week 5: Why Atheists should hope there is a God.

We’ve seen so far that Mawson’s recommendation that atheists should pray are along the right lines: so long as you don’t think prayer is too likely to lead to self delusion, and the costs for the added information are smaller… continue reading »

Why people who boast about their IQ are (generally) losers

- What is your IQ? – I have no idea. People who boast about their IQ are losers – Stephen Hawking A quick and dirty signalling explanation as to why Hawking is right:

Atheist Prayer Experiment, Week 4: What if there’s no answer?

[Belated updates as I've been working in A&E.] Nothing much happened this week. So, instead, lets talk about divine hiddenness: It is implied by the rationale for doing the ‘prayer experiment’ that although a ‘positive result’ has value (“Oh, God… continue reading »

« older posts